Dear President Morales,
I too, am deeply saddened. This is the season of Lent, a time when we are called to look inward and examine ourselves, to prepare for Easter, a time of rebirth. So let us turn inward and examine ourselves individually and in the UUA, shall we?
I think it’s important in this work to be open and honest. I am a cis-gendered, straight white woman. I am a fellowshipped minister serving a parish, and I serve on a District board, so I am quite familiar with governance and regionalization. The opinions here are my own. Our current system privileges me over ministers of color, and often over LGBTQ ministers. If I don’t recognize that and face it, I will never be in a place to change it.
My womb is not wandering, and my response to this crisis (and I do believe it is a crisis) regarding UUA hiring practices is not related in any way to the condition of my uterus. I therefore resent your characterization of peoples’ responses as “hysterical.” Those of us who identify as women are far too familiar with this type of dismissive language.
According to your own biography on the Unitarian Universalist Association (UUA) website, you served on the Unitarian Universalist Ministers Association (UUMA) Executive Committee “as the first person to carry its anti-racism, anti-oppression, multiculturalism portfolio.” Given this credential, I would expect a more culturally sensitive response.
In fact, when looking outward, you have often given thoughtful and sensitive responses. In February of 2010 you wrote a moving letter to the Unitarian Universalists of Uganda, praising them for their, “…courageous stand on behalf of gay and lesbian citizens…”. In November of 2015, you urged us as Unitarian Universalists to learn to follow rather than insisting on taking the lead, and to learn to respond, as we worked as allies with Black Lives matter (read here). In December, 2014, following the horrible decision in the Eric Garner case, you said, “…Eric Garner is dead. Michael Brown is dead. And we must raise our voices, again and again, to proclaim that black lives matter.” (read the whole statement here). You made a similar statement in August of 2014 following the Michael Brown decision.
Even when talking about the UUA, at least in general terms, and when talking about the state of ministry in congregations, you have been aware of the numbers for some time. In the summer 2010 issue of the UU World, you wrote in “The New America“:
Yet during this time the number of minority ministers has changed hardly at all. What is even more troubling, ministers from historic minorities have had great difficulty finding and keeping positions. Why is it that in a generation the situation of women and lesbians and gays in our ministry has changed dramatically while the situation of ethnic and racial minorities has changed hardly at all?
I know that the hardest work is the work we have to do in ourselves. The time is overdue for the UUA to do this work. It is not enough to rest on the laurels of the 2016 Ends Monitoring Report. It is a monitoring report. It doesn’t say “mission accomplished.” It will not do to “whitesplain” or “mansplain” anymore. When those among us who have been historically marginalized are telling us that they are once again being marginalized, we cannot simply tell them they are being “hysterical.” We must pay attention. A good starting place will be the statement from Black Lives of UUs here and The Reflection on White Supremacy in Our UUA from the staff of Youth and Young Adult Ministries here.
The UUA, and in particular, the American Unitarian Association, has a long and ugly history of racism. We must face it, own it, and repair it. In 1903, the AUA published The Blood of The Nation, a horrid treatise promoting eugenics and warning against the dangers of defiling the pure white blood of Americans with inferior races. One hundred and fourteen years on, it’s time that we stop assuming that white is default or superior. It’s time to examine our excuses. It’s time to do the real work.
That’s my mite. It’s all I’ve got.
Update: 30 March, 2017
Dear President Morales,
I have just read your letter to the UUA Board of Trustees in which you announced your intention to step down as President effective 1 April. I commend you for this difficult decision. Your letter is eloquent and thoughtful, and an example of the best of ministry. In doing this difficult thing you are setting an example for all of us in that you are putting the needs of the UUA before your own. I share your prayer that we will come together, listen deeply to one another, and reaffirm our commitment to one another. After all, we are a covenantal faith — what have we got if we don’t have our covenant?
Yours in faith,
The Mite-y Widow